Us-Them

Loving Kindness is a compassion practice which involves both feelings and wishes. It mobilizes the prefrontal language and intention networks as well as limbic emotion and reward networks.

Chenango State Park Area- New York State: 2022-October : One of my thinking places where I try to expand my thinking on Ten Thousand Things about the factors and forces, DNA and Development of difficult persons. It helps in my Loving Kindness Practices

Scenario – Ben (a composite) talked about his lack of assertiveness in the face of an angry aggressive landlord.

Ben- I should have been able to stand up to this bully. He showed disrespect to my wife.

Counselor (PB)- How did that make you feel towards yourself, your wife, the landlord

B- It is a recurring theme, when I have not been able to assert myself.

PB- Can we do a ABC worksheet and see how the situation leads to some beliefs, and what are the emotional consequences of holding on to these beliefs.

We then did a ABC sheet, saw the automatic thoughts which arise, gave rating to the feelings related to these thoughts, examined evidence for and against and re-rating the feelings. This way of thought stop, cognitive reframing, seeing the cognitive distortions such as jumping to conclusions, fortune telling, mind reading, all or none thinking, emotional reasoning is a powerful way to gain perspective. (see worksheets below for download)

Keeping the heart open-Being aware of Us versus them

Another way to approach the above scenario calls for equanimity to keep the heart open, especially in the face of pain or provocation. Kindness for everyone “Omitting none” is an exercise in which all beings are held as “us” in your heart. 

         Five types of persons you can offer kindness is to : Benefactors, friends, neutral people, difficult people and yourself.

In above scenario the Ten thousand things exercise is a way to decrease the ill-will

B-I was not able to assert myself. He was rude, aggressive and inconsiderate to my wife.

PB- Can we go back and scan yourself for ill-will. Where in your body do you feel that? How was your tone? What did you do as follow-up?

B- I wrote a long letter to him to tell him how he was off the line, and it was not good.
Pb- Let us step back and try to reflect on the ten thousand things that have led this person to act in this way. Consider his biologically based factors: like pain, age, temperament, or intelligence.
B- Well that makes me see his day, how he must have felt when he got the news of the flooding of his apartment. He himself is an immigrant like me.
Pb- Consider the realities of his life: responsibilities and stresses

Commentary: The ten thousand things help consider persons in light of whatever you know or can reasonably guess about them, the factors and forces that have shaped their lives. It can be a powerful way to neutralize ill-will and bring a difficult person into being held as “us” in one’s heart and then offer loving kindness.

References:

Burns, D. D. (1989). The feeling good handbook: Using the new mood therapy in everyday life. William Morrow & Co.

 Hanson, R. (2009). Buddha’s brain: The practical neuroscience of happiness, love, and wisdom. New Harbinger Publications.

ABC Worksheet

Worksheet_ Loving Kindness

Posted in Counselling Blogs | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Sagar is 25: Positive Thinking to Positive Experiences

On his 25th birthday, we went from Mississauga to New York and stayed with him.

Due to holiday scheduling we went separately, the advantage being that we were with him for almost a month. On the morning of February 4-Sunday, we went to Marble Collegiate Church and prayed. I told Sagar about the MC and the links with the writings of Dr.Norman Vincent Peale (NVP) which I first started reading in India in the 1980s. As we walked through the Met Museum later in the afternoon, I peeled different layers of life in India when I was around 25 years old, the way my father would come to Delhi hostel and we would have a meal together in Golcha of DaryaGanj.

We shared about the struggles of young adulthood and I did a modification of the Healing by Memories exercise which I was taught by a mentor in Manresa.

Healing By Memories – one has to imagine and go back into the time when one was born and the conditions, atmosphere, dynamics of the family and society at that time. This can be done for different phases of one’s life , like the first time when one went to school. Or the first time when one started staying alone , away from family.

Going beyond Positive Thinking to Positive Experience

Dr NVP prayers like Pray to the God who made me, to remake me, have been refined over the years.The Positive experience layer to positive thinking makes the exercise a deeper experience.  Museums with children, letters to loved ones who have passed away, walks and gratitudes together are some ways we have enhanced our experiences over the decades.

Flashcards and the Family Altar

Family Altar- Around these collages, we discussed about nuances of the journeys of the family, the walks in Shimla of 1940s, North East India 1960s and Maharashtra-Pune Mumbai Aurangabad in 1970s. The spiritual traditions of Father Agnel and Jalaram Bapa. I told about the beads from the Himalayas- The Rudraksha which my mother used to pray with, and the beads I got from Niagara on the Lake-2023-August. These exercises and associations make positive thinking more embedded experience.

               In October 2022 when Sagar first shifted to Elmhurst, after two air bnb stints we came from Mississauga and brought some pictures and collages as momentoes. One of the framed pictures was that of my parents -just married- Jan 30,1967. As we lit candles, I told him about the Benares of the 1960s, his great grandfather and great grandmother- Ganesh and Kamla Uniyal and the way my father found a life of the family through marriage and the linked associations which was different from the Shimla life of the 1940s, 1950s. My father’s mother passed away when he was less than five years old. He often told about the mother he did not have, the ways of the joint family and how he came to Delhi to study for his premedical and then joined AIIMS-Delhi in 1958.

Our Journeys Together: After Marble we went to Met. Worship and Museums together have been part of the family tradition. Later in the week, I went to Barre- (Barre Centre of Buddhist Studies-BCBS), Central Massachusetts for a retreat. The Mindfulness of Death special retreat facilitator Nikki Mirgafori told us to do many unique creative exercises. One of them was to write the names of loved ones who have passed and then group read them together, and then places those papers in a common altar which was in the Meditation Hall for the five days of the Retreat.

My father’s first posting when he was around 25-the age which Sagar is now, was to the North East (Shillong-1963). Over the decades, there were many such tours of duty to the North East. The early, mid nineteen sixties was a time for rebuilding the Eastern front. The recent movie “Sam  Bahadur” tells how then Major General (Later Field Marshal) Manekshaw took control of the Eastern Command and told his troops that they were not to withdraw from their positions unless he gives a written order, and that order is not going to come.

The picture below the marriage picture of my parents is in Maharashtra around 1976. We stayed in Pune and Khadki cantonments. Institutional and organization memories were ingrained into us, and the personal family library has been a tradition which my grandparents and parents instilled into us. Our visits to Ajanta Ellora caves of Maharashtra which represent  ancient monasteries (Viharas) and worship-halls (Chaityas) of different Buddhist traditions carved into a 75-metre (246 ft) wall of rock.

Food for thought
            Write about some memories, dialogues, places you went together with someone you loved and cared for. This will enhance the positive thinking and help absorb them in your being, making them embedded experiences.

Earlier perspectives

Palam

Benares

Rathburn

Posted in life | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Dera

Winter Rose blooming at 697 Candlestick – 2024 January: Reminds of the words of Ruskin Bond – life has not been a bed of roses but I have had some roses out of season.

Jackson Heights – around ten years ago, (2015) while visiting Mississauga from Tripoli, family showed me the serial ” Jackson Heights” . It follows the life of immigrants in New York, through the story of a taxi driver and his association with a hard working married lady who works in a Beauty parlour ( Learning from literature tool)

JOURNEYS, MAPS, TERRITORIES

After an uneventful flight from Pearson to LaGuardia, got down at 90- Elmhurst -Route 7 and reached Sagar’s home before 130 pm just as he was finishing a  meeting.

Dera – Jackson Heights: A meal together

 We walked on 37th Avenue, on way to Dera, an Indian restaurant. Passed Kalpana Chawla way on 37 th , with TD Bank at that intersection.

On being asked when I first tasted Palak chicken, I told of Khadki cantonment days early 1970 s. We used to live in 24 Bombay Poona road. My mother cooked like her mother did in Benares. Our families have lived in university campuses or cantonments which have a different nuance and rhythm of life.

The meal together at Dera reminded me of the many meals we had in Safir Tripoli Libya, and the discussions on African Indian Diaspora, life during Gaddafi’s Libya and how things shaped up after the end of that regime.

READINGS AND METTA VARIATIONS

My parents instilled in me a love for reading. 

The reading and discussing of a book is a tradition which we have followed for decades. In that spirit, as we returned back to Elbertson , we went through excerpts of Living Kindness by Kevin Griffin.

Metta Meditation tradition sends peace, happiness,health , safety, at ease, free from Suffering wishes of compassion to benefactors, mentors, friends, family, neutral persons, difficult persons, the group and the tradition. 

Digesting difficult things : Variations of Metta Meditation

 Jung said that if we don’t digest difficult things it will run our lives. The variation of Metta which accepts and processes difficult things can be broken down into manageable parts. This concept was given a different twist when we read Tonglen meditation done on the occasion of 9/11 ( 2001) when the practitioners were told to be open to the pain and anger of the persons who planned and executed the attack. 23 years on, and the destruction of many countries later – one remembers the words of Nietzsche – that in trying to exterminate monsters one should be mindful not to become a monster oneself

SOME CONVERSATIONS

Some conversations on 37 th 

While returning we walked past the post office, school buildings of Jackson Heights which were looking majestic in the evening

Pb : Walk slowly as otherwise I later get a lot of pain in the knee

Sagar : This is because of genetics ( my mother, his grandmother – died in 2011 after complications on being admitted for knee replacement surgery…she died before the surgery)

Pb – these things are taken care of, not cured

 We are spirits and will pass one day

S – When did you start eating Palak chicken ( an Indian dish with spinach)

P – my mother made it- early 1970 s, Pune and the last time was in an Indian restaurant in Mississauga 

S – So your mother was non vegetarian

P – we come from a military family

.

Memorable walks at Queens New York

Earlier perspectives

2019 June : Riverwood Mississauga

  Conversations on eve of China trip

Posted in life | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment